top of page

How to Get Your First 1000 Email Subscribers: A Small Business Owner’s Playbook

Writer's picture: Skyler TalleySkyler Talley

Updated: Nov 11, 2024


one million email subscribers dr evil


Alright, listen up, small business warriors. Ready to level up your game by building an email list? Let’s get one thing straight—those 1,000 subscribers aren’t just going to appear like magic. They’re out there, floating around in the abyss of the internet, just waiting to be snatched up by a savvy entrepreneur like yourself. Building a killer email list can be the difference between a business that limps along and one that conquers its niche with ease. So buckle up, because we’re going to get you those subscribers without sending you into a financial or mental meltdown.

And here’s the big secret those massive brands don’t want you to know: email marketing is their secret weapon. Yup, it’s not some mystical, high-budget ad campaign or a big influencer flex—it’s email. They’ve been quietly building their lists while everyone else is out there groveling for likes on social media. And guess what? It works. But the best part? You can do it too, and probably do it better.


Why You Need an Email List (As in, Yesterday)

Social media algorithms are the fickle tyrants of the digital kingdom. One day you’re on top, and the next you’re buried under a pile of ads for teeth-whitening kits. But your email list? That’s yours. Forever. No algorithm, no Zuckerberg, no TikTok teen with a million followers can take it away. It’s your golden ticket to reach your customers directly, no middleman required. And here’s the kicker—done right, email marketing delivers an ROI of 4200%. That’s not a typo.

With a solid email list, you can build meaningful relationships, send offers people actually want to see, and direct serious traffic to your site. But first, you need subscribers. And not just any subscribers—you need 1,000 die-hard fans. Let’s talk about how you’re going to do that.


Step 1: Get a Lead Magnet That’ll Knock Their Socks Off

No one’s handing over their email address just because you’re charming. You need something irresistible, something that screams “click me.” Enter: the lead magnet. This little freebie should offer so much value that they’d feel ridiculous passing it up.

What could it be? A well-designed e-book full of juicy info (think “10 Secrets to Making Your First Million” or whatever floats their boat). A discount code that makes them feel like they’re beating the system. Exclusive video content that they’ll brag about watching. Templates, checklists, webinars, you name it. Whatever it is, it needs to solve a problem for them or make their life easier. Your goal? Make them think, “Wow, how did I survive without this?”


Step 2: Pop-Ups and Opt-In Forms, But Don’t Be a Nuisance

Next up, you’ve got to catch them while they’re on your site. But, if you bombard them with pop-ups like some overeager car salesman, they’re out of there. Here’s the secret: exit-intent pop-ups. These beauties only show up when someone’s about to leave your site, giving them a last chance to sign up before they disappear forever. It’s like you’re dangling a lifeline.

Oh, and keep it simple. No one wants to fill out a full questionnaire just to get on your list. Name and email, that’s it. Anything more, and you’re shooting yourself in the foot.


Step 3: Work Social Media Like a Pro (Because You’re Not a Newbie)

Social media isn’t just for vanity metrics—it’s your hunting ground for subscribers. But for the love of all things holy, please don’t post a lame “sign up for our newsletter” plea. That’s as compelling as a wet paper towel. Instead, get creative. Host an Instagram giveaway where entry requires signing up for your email list. Make a TikTok showcasing behind-the-scenes magic with a sneaky “want more? Subscribe for the insider scoop” at the end. Use Facebook posts to hype up the exclusive perks of being on your list.

And if you’re not linking to that lead magnet in your bio, you’re missing out. Use a bio tool like Linktree or Beacons to direct followers to the goods.


Step 4: Turn Your Website Into a Subscriber Magnet

Think of your website as a subscriber trap. They’ve already made it there, so your job is to reel them in. Don’t just slap an opt-in form in the footer and call it a day. That’s amateur hour. Add your sign-up form in the footer, header, blog posts, and landing pages. Make sure it’s sprinkled throughout the site—every time they scroll, they should see another opportunity to subscribe.

Your website should be screaming, “Come for the content, stay for the exclusive goodies.” If they’re not subscribing, you’ve got some work to do.


Step 5: Get Your Current Subscribers to Spread the Gospel

Have a few subscribers already? Great—use them as your unpaid (or maybe slightly rewarded) sales team. If they’re loving your emails, they’ll want to share. Encourage them to forward your newsletters with a simple “share with a friend” button. Better yet, offer a referral program. Give subscribers an incentive to bring their friends in—think discounts, freebies, or access to exclusive content.

Remember, word of mouth is powerful, and if you’ve already got fans, they’ll be your best marketers.


Step 6: Team Up with Other Businesses and Influencers

Two heads are better than one, right? Partner up with other businesses that target similar audiences but aren’t direct competitors. A fitness studio could team up with a health food store, a local coffee shop with a bakery. You promote their list, they promote yours—everyone wins.

Don’t underestimate influencers, either. You don’t need a Kardashian to get traction. Micro-influencers—those with a smaller but dedicated following—can do wonders for building your list. Offer them something valuable for their audience (a special discount, exclusive content, etc.) in exchange for promoting your email list. Their followers trust them, and they’ll trust you by association.


Step 7: Use Paid Ads for Lead Generation (If You’re Willing to Spend a Little)

Got some budget? Good. Put it to work with paid ads focused on lead generation. Facebook and Google Ads can be incredibly effective when you’re promoting a lead magnet. Create ads that emphasize the benefit of joining your list—don’t make it about you, make it about them and how signing up will change their lives.

When they click, make sure they’re sent to a high-converting landing page that does one thing and one thing only: gets them to subscribe. No distractions, no fluff, just straight-up value.


Step 8: Let SEO Do the Heavy Lifting

Picture this: your email list grows while you sleep. Sounds like a dream, right? That’s where SEO comes in. Create valuable, keyword-rich blog content that brings organic traffic to your site. Target your audience’s biggest questions and pain points, and show them that you’ve got the answers.

Each blog post should have opt-in forms scattered throughout—don’t miss a single opportunity. By building up your SEO game, you’ll get traffic and subscribers without constantly lifting a finger. It’s the gift that keeps on giving.


So, What’s Next?

Look at you, all equipped with the blueprint to hit that 1,000-subscriber mark. But let’s make sure this guide doesn’t just sit on your website, collecting dust. Optimize the heck out of this content with SEO-friendly keywords—“how to grow your email list,” “email marketing strategies for small businesses,” and “lead generation secrets” should be peppered throughout.

Promote this bad boy on every channel. Share blog snippets, turn sections into quick social media posts, and repurpose it into video content. And if you really want to supercharge things, run Google Ads targeted at small business owners and entrepreneurs who need to boost their email lists.

Better yet, tap into the influence of small business personalities. A shoutout from a well-placed influencer can bring a new wave of subscribers straight to your door.


Building the Right Kind of Email List

Remember, you’re not building just any list—you’re building the right list. We’re talking about subscribers who are genuinely interested in what you have to say, not just people looking to grab a quick freebie and run. These subscribers are your people. They’re the ones who’ll engage, support, and eventually become loyal customers.

Commit to this. Build your email list with intention, and don’t be afraid to have a little fun with it. Keep it edgy, keep it real, and keep those subscribers coming back for more. Before you know it, you’ll have a list of fans waiting for every email, every update, and every offer. Now go out there and get those 1,000 subscribers—and make them count.


a winning email campaign


4 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page